
Short answer: Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) is new enough that the market is full of agencies relabelling ordinary SEO as “AI search” work. Before signing with anyone, watch for vague AI-citation reporting and promises to “guarantee” a ChatGPT or AI Overview mention. Also be wary of long lock-in contracts for a discipline nobody has a multi-year track record in yet, and GEO bolted onto a site with no real technical foundation underneath it. Any one of these is worth a direct follow-up question. Two or more is a real warning sign.
Why GEO hiring needs more scrutiny than a typical SEO vendor pitch
Direct answer: Because GEO has no long-established standards body, no agreed reporting format, and a shorter track record than classic SEO. That makes it easier for an agency to sell the label without the substance behind it.
Search engine optimisation has been a recognisable discipline for over two decades, with broadly agreed reporting conventions (rankings, organic traffic, backlinks). GEO means getting a business mentioned and cited by AI tools like Google’s AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. As a sold service, it is only a few years old. That gap matters at the hiring stage. Right now, it’s easy for an agency to add “GEO” or “AEO” to a service list without having built real reporting, a real methodology, or any real client results in it. For the underlying technical distinctions, see What Is Generative Engine Optimisation and Answer Engine Optimisation Explained. For what to actively ask instead, see How to Choose a GEO Agency in Australia.
1. They can’t show you a real AI-citation metric — only rankings
Direct answer: If an agency’s “GEO reporting” is a standard keyword-rank report with an AI label on top, that’s not GEO reporting.
Ranking position tells you where a page sits in classic search. It doesn’t tell you whether an AI assistant is actually naming your business in its answer. Ask to see a live example of AI-mention or AI-citation tracking for an existing client before you sign. Not a description of it, the actual report.
2. They guarantee a specific AI outcome
Direct answer: Nobody controls what a third-party AI model decides to say. So a guaranteed placement, mention, or ranking inside ChatGPT, Gemini, or Google’s AI Overviews is not a promise any credible agency can actually keep.
A reasonable agency will talk about structuring content and schema to improve the odds of citation. It will also discuss realistic timelines based on topic competitiveness. An agency promising a specific, guaranteed AI result is overselling the work, or it doesn’t understand how these systems actually generate answers.
3. Long lock-in contracts, with no clear exit terms
Direct answer: A 12–24 month lock-in is a harder ask to justify in a discipline that’s barely a few years old. It’s worth asking in the same breath what happens to your content and data if you do leave.
Ask directly what happens if the relationship isn’t working after three or four months. Then get the data/content handover terms in writing before signing. Not after a dispute. Sharp Instincts’ own standing terms apply across all services, including GEO: no contracts, no minimum term and no notice period. We also keep a client’s work-in-progress materials for three months after the relationship ends, handing them over on request within that window. Some clients have stayed 10+ years on that basis, without ever having needed a contract to keep them.
4. No real, checkable example of their own GEO work
Direct answer: A client logo list isn’t proof of GEO-specific work. Ask for a real example of content or schema they built or refreshed for AI extraction. Then check whether the schema they’re describing actually renders live on the page (a surprising number of sites ship visible FAQ copy with no working schema behind it at all).
5. They sell GEO to clients but don’t use it themselves
Direct answer: An agency pushing AI-era marketing on clients while running its own operations the old way is a yellow flag. It is worth a direct question. Sharp Instincts runs its own internal AI tools: Sharp Instincts Sage and the Sharp Connect MCP Automations system. It does not only sell AI-related services outward, which is the kind of concrete answer worth asking any agency to match.
6. A vague, open-ended scope that keeps adding billable “AI” line items
Direct answer: Watch for an agency that answers every follow-up question with a new, separately billed “AI” add-on. That suggests nobody properly scoped the engagement in the first place.
Ask for a written scope before signing. Exactly what your price point includes and what counts as GEO-specific work versus general content. Also, what (if anything) triggers an additional charge. A credible agency can answer this upfront. One relying on scope creep to pad billings usually can’t, or won’t put it in writing.
7. GEO sold without a technical SEO foundation underneath it
Direct answer: GEO draws on the same technical SEO and content foundations as classic search. A site with broken indexing, no working schema, or years of technical debt won’t earn AI citations just because an agency starts publishing “AI-optimised” content on top of it.
Ask whether a technical SEO audit comes before any GEO work, not alongside or after it. Some agencies jump straight to GEO-flavoured content. If they skip checking the site’s indexing and technical health, they are treating a structural problem with a cosmetic fix.
8. GEO pricing that’s unclear or bundled without explanation
Direct answer: Ask directly whether your package includes GEO or the agency bills it as an extra. Also ask at what spend level that changes. A vague answer here usually means the agency hasn’t actually thought the pricing model through.
At Sharp Instincts, clients on the Growth ($3,000–$5,000/month) or Authority ($5,000+/month) tiers get GEO and AI-automation work included within their existing package at no extra cost. On the Foundation tier (around $1,500/month), we bill GEO work as an additional cost on top of the existing SEO package. See the full breakdown on Sharp Instincts’ SEO pricing page.
9. Treats GEO as a one-off project rather than ongoing work
Direct answer: AI models retrain and update constantly, and competitors keep publishing. A single round of “GEO-optimised” content isn’t a finished job, it’s a starting point that needs ongoing maintenance the same way SEO does.
If an agency frames GEO as a fixed-scope, one-time deliverable rather than continuous work, ask how they plan to keep content current as AI models and competitor content change.
A quick gut check before you commit
If two or more of the red flags above apply to an agency you’re evaluating, treat that as a reason to keep looking rather than hope it works out. For the companion checklist of what to actively ask a GEO agency, see How to Choose a GEO Agency in Australia. If you’re evaluating an AI automation or AI-agent partner alongside a GEO agency, a related but distinct hire, see How to Choose an AI Automation Agency in Australia.
About Sharp Instincts’ own approach
Sharp Instincts is a Melbourne-based digital marketing agency, co-founded in 2016 by Richard Monheit and Vikrant Thakur, with a team of 30+ working as an embedded, long-term partner for Australian SMEs across GEO, AEO, SEO, paid media, and web/app development. No contracts, no minimum term. A 5.0-star rating on Google reviews, and a 4.1 “Great” TrustScore on Trustpilot.
Want a second opinion on an agency you’re evaluating, or want to see how Sharp Instincts structures its own GEO work? Get in touch for a free audit and discovery call. No obligation, and no contract to sign afterward if it isn’t the right fit.
Frequently asked questions
What are the biggest red flags when hiring a GEO or AI-search agency?
Vague or absent AI-citation reporting (only rankings, no real mention/citation data), guaranteed AI placement promises, long lock-in contracts with no clear exit terms, no real checkable example of their own GEO work, and GEO sold without a technical SEO foundation underneath it.
Can an agency guarantee a mention in ChatGPT or Google’s AI Overviews?
No. Nobody controls what a third-party AI model decides to say in its answers, so a guaranteed AI placement, mention, or citation is not a promise any credible agency can actually deliver. Be cautious of anyone offering one.
Does GEO work require a technical SEO foundation first?
Yes, in practice. GEO draws on the same technical SEO and content foundations as classic search. A site with broken indexing or no working schema is unlikely to earn AI citations just because someone labels new content “GEO-optimised.”
Is a long contract normal for GEO services?
Not necessarily, and it’s worth more scrutiny than a long SEO contract would get, given how new and fast-changing GEO still is. Sharp Instincts, for comparison, applies no contracts or minimum term to any of its services, including GEO.
What should I ask about pricing before signing with a GEO agency?
Whether an existing package includes GEO or the agency bills it as a separate add-on. Also ask at what spend level that changes. At Sharp Instincts, GEO is included at no extra cost for clients on the Growth or Authority tiers (roughly $2,000/month spend or above). Below that, it’s billed as an additional cost on the Foundation tier.
Write A Comment
Prefer to talk? Book a time with Richard or call 1800 512 124.

Red Flags When Hiring an AI-Search or GEO Agency in Australia